Across the road from Bethleem Farm East Cemetery Baldrick, still shell-shocked, attempts to clean the mud off his car with handfuls of grass! No, it was never really going to work, now was it.
A grassy track thankfully leads us through this sodden field towards the cemetery. The rebuilt Messines Church is not far away on the horizon to the north west. The southern edge of the Messines Ridge doesn’t appear to be much of a ridge at all from this viewpoint.
The cemetery name is clearly inscribed as Bethleem Farm West Military Cemetery, yet nowhere else can I find the word ‘Military’ in association with this place, including on the cemetery plan, as you will see, which would have been originally drawn up in the 1920s. I am beginning to wonder whether it was an error by the stonemason, and that ‘Military’ should never have been inscribed on the cemetery entrance at all.
Cemetery entrance and register box.
The cemetery consists of six long lines of headstones, as you can see on the cemetery plan below, and was begun by the Australians on the first day of the Battle of Messines, 7th June 1917.
Bethleem Farm West Military Cemetery Plan
The Australians originally called the cemetery ‘3rd Division General Cemetery’ and it was used until just before Christmas 1917. By far the majority of the 164* burials here, 113 of them, are Australians; during May and June 1917 35 officers and 1631 men of the A.I.F. were killed in the Ploegsteert/Messines area. Just the day before the battle here began, on the 6th June, many Australians had been caught by German gas shells as they made their way up the Ploegsteert trenches towards the front line ready for the attack. Caught before they could don, and in some cases without, their gas masks, the Australians sustained some 500 casualties and were so delayed that some men reached the front line and, without stopping, continued over the top as the mines exploded away to both their left and right and the battle began.
*The CWGC Casualty Details List records 165 burials in total, but one man enlisted under an alias and is listed under both names.
Three Australians of the 30th Battalion, all killed, one would presume together, on 18th November 1917. Left to right:
|PRIVATE A, H, HUNTRISS||30th BN, AUSTRALIAN INFANTRY||26||18/11/1917||F 7|
|CORPORAL A. G. FARMER||30th BN, AUSTRALIAN INFANTRY||22||18/11/1917||F 7A|
|PRIVATE E. V. TAYLOR||30th BN, AUSTRALIAN INFANTRY||u/k||18/11/1917||F 7B|
All the burials here are identified except this one unknown soldier of the Second World War, whose story we will sadly never know.
23 men of the New Zealand Rifle Brigade lie buried here, all killed in August 1917.
More New Zealand casualties. Left to right:
|LIEUTENANT E. A. MAUDE||NEW ZEALAND RIFLE BRIGADE||35||18/08/1917||D 3|
|PRIVATE W, E, CODD||WELLINGTON REGIMENT, N. Z. E. F.||26||16/08/1917||D 4|
|SERJEANT R. W. GUY||OTAGO REGIMENT, |
N. Z. E. F.
There is one burial from earlier in 1917, that of Private Harold Brooksbank, but I rather suspect he was originally buried nearby, or his body was found nearby, and moved to Bethleem Farm West after the tide of war had moved east. Update November 2018: The real reason behind the date on Private Brooksbank’s headstone can now be found among the comments that follow this post.
Three more men of the Machine Gun Corps, all buried here on the same day in September 1917. I’d like to know whether there’s a reason why two men of the Machine Gun Corps (Infantry) are buried next to a Cavalry machine gunner, which makes them unlikely to be part of the same machine gun team. Or am I wrong in that assumption? Left to right:
|PRIVATE J. H. COTTON||MACHINE GUN CORPS (INFANTRY)||22||03/09/1917||D 28|
|LANCE CORPORAL G. W. BATE*||MACHINE GUN CORPS (INFANTRY)||21||03/09/1917||D 29|
|PRIVATE G. FAIRBROTHER||MACHINE GUN CORPS (CAVALRY)||23||03/09/1917||D 30|
*Lance Corporal Bate’s brother, Private J. T. Bate, King’s Shropshire Light Infantry, killed on the 9th August 1915 aged 21, is also remembered on the headstone.
Six Australian headstones, casualties from July 1917, buried together in Row B.
This view looks north west, the six Australian graves in the previous photo in Row B to the right, and the Irish Peace Tower on the horizon to the left.
I believe that the Cross of Sacrifice pictured here has been replaced by a new one since our visit. As I am occasionally wont to remind you, the CWGC’s work of maintaining the cemeteries along the Western Front, and elsewhere, never ceases.
Looking south east past the Cross of Sacrifice across the headstones of Rows D (far right) to A in the background.
Four men of the Royal Scots Fusiliers were buried here on 1st September 1917. The three pictured above are, left to right:
|LANCE CORPORAL W. McLEAN||ROYAL SCOTS FUSILIERS||u/k||01/09/1917||D 24|
|PRIVATE J. RENWICK||ROYAL SCOTS FUSILIERS||u/k||01/09/1917||D 25|
|PRIVATE T. DONNELLY||ROYAL SCOTS FUSILIERS||u/k||01/09/1917||D 26|
Australian grave, Canadian flag. Rest in peace, Private Willmer.
“What’s that Balders? Time to call it a day? Yes, I think you’re probably right. I suppose I’m paying for the carwash? Thought so. So who’s paying for the beers?”
Somebody did. End of a long and eventful day.
In reference to Pvt. Willmer (Canadian flag, Australian grave), I am looking to see if there is any Canadian family connection. Did find an Australian Red Cross record that might be of interest.
Australia Birth Index, 1788-1922 about James Herrold Willmer (sic from Ancestry)
Name: James Herrold Willmer
Birth Date: 21 Oct 1894
Father’s Name: John Willmer
Mother’s Name: Eliza Ellis
Birth Place: Queensland
Registration Year: 1894
Registration Place: Queensland
Page Number: 28267
Registration number: B055519
Good job both. We knew nothing about James Willmer yesterday, and now he’s been in at least three people’s thoughts for the past twenty four hours. Which is rather nice, if you see what I mean.
“There is one burial from early in 1917, that of Private Brooksbank, but I rather suspect he was originally buried nearby, or his body was found nearby, and moved to Bethleem Farm West after the tide of war had moved east.”
Recently, investigations into the date of Private Brooksbank’s death have resulted in the CWGC acknowledging that the headstone date is incorrect, and in due course the headstone date will be corrected – in-situ, or if necessary by a headstone replacement.
The correct date of death is 23 July 1917, which matches that of the adjacent grave of Private Selwyn Lawrence of the same Machine Gun Company. Both soldiers had been attached to the Australian Imperial Forces, and were killed by a shell exploding in their trench. Thanks for photographing the Brooksbank headstone.
Further information can be found at:-
Nice work – I have inspected the documents etc via the link you gave. Such things are very dear to my heart. It’s a good feeling when one’s research comes up trumps. I know. And coincidentally, there may be a post here in the next few months about a very similar situation. Cheers Barry, thanks for letting us know. I just love it when good people add to the stories of these cemeteries. I’d appreciate knowing when the headstone has been replaced if you become aware – it will need to be photographed.
I have updated the post by referring people to your comment; he now has a first name here too.
Just been looking more into this and it is surely a slam dunk. The date on the headstone is a totally mad date. Has the CWGC database been updated since your submission, ‘cos it says 23rd July now? I should have looked into this back in 2013 when I wrote the post – probably, had I written it today, I would have. This was still quite early in this website’s life.
Yes, CWGC updated their database at 20181129-0727.
Changed date of death, and included Harold as forename.
This reply is out of sequence, but in respect of a change to the date on the headstone, I will be supplied with a photograph of the headstone by CWGC, and will make it available via a webpage link. I will post the details here; but could be some months away if a new headstone is required.
I was originally looking at Bethleem Farm West cemetery in respect of a distant family member – Private William Edward Codd, whose headstone you also photographed. It was only after I downloaded the CWGC data of the cemetery, and created a sortable table, that I really became aware that Pte. H. Brooksbank & Pte. Selwyn Lawrence were the only two MG 207th Coy soldiers attached to the Australian Imperial Force. The fact that one had died 4 months before the other, when the division he was attached to was no where near Messines, got me thinking. So, basically, I set out to find some background to H. Brookbanks, and as we now all know, confirmed what I had suspected, that the date on his headstone was rubbish.
In the process I also learned a good deal about his family, and in a day or so the data included in the La Basse-Ville webpage will be updated to show his DoB, parents, and wife’s name. I have also noted that CWGC have added the forenames of a number of other soldiers at Bethleem Farm West [W.E. Codd was one] – possibly from new data they have acquired.
Pvt Ernest Victor Taylor (on the right in the three headstone picture) was just 24 when he was killed in action ‘in the field’ 18th Nov 1917. Ernest arrived 26th Oct 1917 ‘taken on strength from reinforcement’. He was the youngest of 13 children and was barely two years old when his mother died. Thomas Taylor, Ernest’s father, lived to be 90 but every day bore the pain of losing his son so far from home.
Thanks for taking the time to comment R. Rigney, adding to this post, and keeping the memory of Private Taylor alive.
Pte. Harold Brooksbank’s headstone – referred to in an earlier post – has been repaired by the CWGC, and the supplied photograph of the repair can be found at:-
It’s obviously a candidate for a decent new photograph!
Certainly is Barry – actually, next year, hopefully, I shall return to all the Messines cemeteries – time for a revisit (same applies with Ploegsteert – ten years since I last spent serious time in the area). I have quite a big list – well, it would be if I had actually kept a list, which I haven’t (doh!) – of headstones with incorrect information, mainly names spelled wrong – there’s a good example here of an incorrect name https://thebignote.com/2016/07/01/the-8th-east-surreys-at-montauban-billie-nevill-carnoy-military-cemetery/ – and wrong dates. In a couple of posts we shall be visiting Bleuet Farm Cemetery, and eagle-eyed me spotted a date error there, as you will see in due course. Big thanks for letting me know and sending the link. There was certainly something not quite right about the grave, hence my comments in the first place.